Today I finally drove the HRV for the first time. It was a short ride in a white LX CVT... the only car my local dealer has on the line, for now, and much in demand for drives. (I did see an MSM EX-L, already sold and prepped for pickup... didn't get to sit in it, but got a good look at the colour, which I really liked.) My wife and I had some interesting reactions, good and bad.
The bottom line is this: while we liked the HR-V and didn't find anything to hate, there were lots of little niggles that added up to to a less than compelling package. Seat comfort, passenger footwell, engine noise, CVT, all-touch interface, interior finish were all disappointing, for us. Cabin noise at cruise, general handling, visibility, size and ride height, fit and finish (mostly, but not always material choice) were all impressive.
Afterwards, after much discussion over a good pub meal on a sunny seaside deck, our current front-runner by a good margin is... (drum roll please)... the Crosstrek. XV. Whatever... the Subie. All subject to another good look and a longer (i.e. overnight) test drive to confirm our initial impressions. We'll also probably drive a manual HR-V when one's available, although most of our disappointments with the HR-V would still be there even if the manual was an exceptional driving experience.
This doesn't mean I'm entirely out of the HR-V camp, but definitely leaning another direction, for now. I can still fully appreciate the appeal of the HR-V... it's a great size, well equipped, at a good price point, by an excellent brand that's had my loyalty for 30-odd years. But in the end, I'm not convinced that there aren't better options out there, at least if you have the means to pay a little more or look at a different class of vehicle (like CR-V / CX-5, or iM, or Golf, or Soul, or ???). If I end up going Subie, I know I'll miss things like lane watch and magic seats that are Honda-only easter eggs.
Sorry this wasn't as long and detailed a review as my Crosstrek thread. Perhaps I'm just not as inspired... which should tell me something. (I think Gruenie's known all along...)